Direct answer: most BJJ gear is a bad gift. These ten are the exceptions.
The other Hotline post says skip the gear. It means most of it. A gi in the wrong size or a mouthguard he didn't pick is a guess dressed as a gift. Everything below is something I'd hand a training partner myself. That's the whole test.
1. Ranked rash guard, about $20 to $80. Match the color to his belt rank. It's personal, and there's no sizing gamble. A white belt in a white rash guard looks right. A purple belt in purple looks like he planned it, which he did. Personal, safe, and cheaper than the gi you were going to buy. Tatami's ranked line comes in all six belt colors.
2. Private lessons, $80 to $200 depending on the gym. One hour of one-on-one beats a month of regular classes. His coach will find the three things he's been doing wrong for a year and fix them in an afternoon. That's the feature and the threat. IMPORTANT: Just make sure to book through his own gym, with his own coach. Book them at the gym across town and he'll spend a year paying for it. Not in money. His fingers will need the tape at #3 afterward.
3. Monkey Tape, about $10 to $13 for a four-pack. Tape runs out. It runs out faster than seems reasonable, and always when he needs it most. Every grappler's fingers are a long-term project, and this is the material. The stocking stuffer that always gets used, because it always gets used up. Monkey Tape's four-pack on Amazon.
4. Theragun Mini, about $199. For the grappler who's always sore. Which, given enough years on the mat, is all of them. It's the expensive answer to a real problem: everything hurts, and he's too stubborn to rest. If you'd rather someone else do the work, see #8. The Theragun Mini on Amazon.
5. Gold BJJ Randori Duffel, about $70 to $100. The waterproof pocket for the sweaty gi is the whole pitch. Everything else stays dry on the drive home. The front pocket fits his tape and his keys, which makes this the natural home for #3. A bag is the rare gear gift that can't be the wrong size. The Randori Duffel on Amazon.
6. BJJ Fanatics instructionals, $47 to $197 per course. The gift of skill. Digital delivery means it still works on December 23rd. Think of it as the private lesson at #2, except it's three in the morning and the instructor is a world champion who doesn't know he exists. Gift cards are available if you'd rather let him pick. BJJ Fanatics gift cards.
7. Custom embroidered belt. Premium, and the price depends on the maker. A belt with his name on it is the milestone gift, best saved for upper belts. If the rash guard at #1 marks where he is, this marks how he got there. Check with his instructor before you order one. A belt is close enough to a promotion that you don't surprise anyone with it.
8. Massage gift certificate. Price depends on where you live. Recovery every grappler needs. This is #4 with a human being attached, which some people prefer. It's also the only item on this list where he has to do absolutely nothing, and after years of shrimping, he's earned that. Massage Envy sells gift cards online.
9. Grappling dummy, $47 to $142 unfilled. The range is wide because sizes and materials vary. It ships unfilled, so the filling is on you, and it needs floor space. Only buy this if he has room for it. On the other hand, it's the one training partner who never cancels and never gets injured. He also never taps, which you can read however you like. The DAAN MMA dummy on Amazon.
10. A gift card to a BJJ brand he already likes, $50 and up. The safe fallback. You read nine items and still don't trust your own judgment. That's fine. He knows his size and his taste better than you do, and admitting it is the most honest gift on this list. The Frames Culture Club Gift Card, if he's the shirt type.
That's the list. Ten things, all of them safe to give.
Some of the links above are affiliate links, which means I may earn a commission if you buy through them.